World Library  
Flag as Inappropriate
Email this Article

Stéphane Dion

Article Id: WHEBN0000692732
Reproduction Date:

Title: Stéphane Dion  
Author: World Heritage Encyclopedia
Language: English
Subject: Saint-Laurent (electoral district), Liberal Party of Canada leadership election, 2006, Michael Ignatieff, Liberal Party of Canada, Jean Chrétien
Collection: 1955 Births, Academics in Quebec, Canadian Ministers of Intergovernmental Affairs, Canadian Political Scientists, Canadian Roman Catholics, Canadian Sociologists, French People of Canadian Descent, French Quebecers, Leaders of the Liberal Party of Canada, Leaders of the Opposition (Canada), Liberal Party of Canada Mps, Living People, Members of the House of Commons of Canada from Quebec, Members of the Queen's Privy Council for Canada, Politicians from Quebec City, Sciences PO Alumni, Université De Montréal Faculty, Université Laval Alumni
Publisher: World Heritage Encyclopedia

Stéphane Dion

The Honourable
Stéphane Dion
PC MP   
Leader of the Opposition
In office
December 2, 2006 – December 10, 2008
Monarch Elizabeth II
Governor General Michaëlle Jean
Prime Minister Stephen Harper
Preceded by Bill Graham
Succeeded by Michael Ignatieff
Leader of the Liberal Party of Canada
In office
December 2, 2006 – December 10, 2008
Deputy Michael Ignatieff
Preceded by Bill Graham (interim)
Succeeded by Michael Ignatieff (interim, later elected party leader)
Minister of the Environment
In office
July 20, 2004 – February 6, 2006
Prime Minister Paul Martin
Preceded by David Anderson
Succeeded by Rona Ambrose
President of the Canadian Privy Council
In office
January 25, 1996 – December 11, 2003
Prime Minister Jean Chrétien
Preceded by Marcel Massé
Succeeded by Denis Coderre
Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs
In office
January 25, 1996 – December 11, 2003
Prime Minister Jean Chrétien
Preceded by Marcel Massé
Succeeded by Pierre Pettigrew
Member of the Canadian Parliament
for Saint-Laurent
Assumed office
October 19, 2015
Preceded by Riding Created
Member of the Canadian Parliament
for Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
In office
March 25, 1996 – October 19, 2015
Preceded by Shirley Maheu
Succeeded by Riding Abolished
Personal details
Born Stéphane Maurice Dion
(1955-09-28) 28 September 1955
Quebec City, Quebec, Canada
Political party Liberal Party of Canada
Spouse(s) Janine Krieber
Children Jeanne
Alma mater Université Laval, Sciences Po
Profession Author
professor of political science
Religion Roman Catholic[1]

Stéphane Maurice Dion,[2] PC, MP (born 28 September 1955) has been the Member of Parliament of Canada for the riding of Saint-Laurent—Cartierville in Montreal since 1996. He was the leader of the Liberal Party of Canada and the Leader of the Opposition in the House of Commons of Canada from 2006 to 2008. Dion resigned as Liberal leader after the party's defeat in the 2008 general election, but remained in Parliament and was re-elected in his riding in the 2011 election.

Dion is a former academic who served as a cabinet minister under Jean Chrétien and Paul Martin and, as such, is a Member of the Privy Council.[3]


  • Life before politics 1
  • Early political life 2
  • Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs (January 1996 – December 2003) 3
    • Clarity of referendum question 3.1
    • Supreme Court reference re secession of Quebec 3.2
    • Three letters 3.3
    • First International Conference on Federalism 3.4
    • Clarity Act 3.5
    • Reactions to Clarity Act 3.6
    • Views on federalism 3.7
  • Gomery inquiry and 2004 election (January–July 2004) 4
  • Minister of the Environment (July 2004 – February 2006) 5
  • Liberal leadership candidate (April–December 2006) 6
  • Leader of Her Majesty's Opposition (December 2006 – December 2008) 7
    • Parliamentary Opposition 7.1
    • Internal discord 7.2
    • Visit to Afghanistan 7.3
    • 2008 federal election 7.4
    • Resignation 7.5
      • 2008 parliamentary dispute 7.5.1
  • Post-leadership (January 2009-present) 8
    • 2011 federal election 8.1
    • 2015 federal election 8.2
  • Personal life 9
  • Electoral record 10
  • Notes and references 11
  • External links 12

Life before politics

Dion was born in Quebec City, the second of five children. His mother, Denyse (née Kormann),[4] was a real-estate agent born in Paris, France, and his father, Léon Dion, was a Quebec academic. Dion was raised in a modest home on Liegeois Boulevard in the Sillery, Quebec, today part of Quebec City. While growing up, he remembers being taunted for his family's secularism in a society which was then predominantly Catholic.[5]

He studied political science at Université Laval in the department co-founded by his father;[6] this was also where he met his future wife, Janine Krieber, a fellow-student in the same program. He obtained BA and MA degrees in 1977 and 1979 respectively (his master's thesis presented an analysis of the evolution of Parti Québécois electoral strategies),[7] after which he and Janine departed together for France.

Dion was involved with the sovereignty movement, first as a teenager attending a Jesuit college in Quebec City,[8] and later as a university student campaigning for Parti Québécois candidate Louise Beaudoin in the 1976 election.[9] Mr. Dion described his experience as follows:

Because the party was there... I wanted to challenge my dad... the way to become an adult sometimes is to say the contrary to your father. Each evening, I would try out a new argument I had heard on the separatist network and my father was demolishing it... My father very quietly and very respectfully was refuting me, without insulting me.[8]

Dion has said that his involvement as "an activist for the separatist cause" ended during a five-hour discussion with a federalist household while he was going door-to-door for the PQ, but he did not openly commit to federalism until much later. At the time of the 1980 referendum, his sentiments were neutral. In his own words, the 'no' victory left him "neither moved nor outraged. To tell the truth, I felt no particular feeling." (Moi, je ne me sentais ni ému ni révolté. À vrai dire, je n'éprouvais aucun sentiment particulier.)[10]

Dion spent four years in Paris, living with Janine in the Brookings Institution in Washington, D.C. during a 1990–91 sabbatical leave.[12]

After the failure of the Meech Lake Accord in 1990, Dion directed his intellectual inquiry towards an analysis of Quebec nationalism. His decisive conversion to federalism, as he later recounted to journalist Michel Vastel, occurred as he was preparing for a presentation in Washington:

I was sitting at my computer at 11 o'clock, and, at noon, I had a text that was so interesting that the Americans wanted to publish it. It was on that day that I realized I was truly a federalist. (Je me suis assis devant mon ordinateur à 11 h et, à midi, j'avais un texte tellement intéressant que les Américains ont voulu le publier. C'est ce jour-là que je me suis rendu compte que j'étais vraiment fédéraliste.)[10]

In this period, the sovereignty movement had begun to promote the idea that federalism was inefficient for Quebec due to the duplication and overlap between the two levels of government. An expert in public administration, Dion emerged as a key figure in publicly criticizing this line of argument. His appearances on Le Point, a Télévision de Radio-Canada current affairs program, brought him to the attention of Aline Chrétien, who in the days following the close referendum defeat urged her husband, Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, to recruit him.[8]

Between 1987 and 1995, Dion published a number of books and articles on political science, public administration and management.[13] A collection of Dion's speeches and writings on Canadian unity was published under the title Straight Talk (Le pari de la franchise) in 1999.[14] Dion was also a guest scholar at the Laboratoire d'économie publique de Paris from 1994 to 1995, a co-editor of the Canadian Journal of Political Science from 1990 to 1993, and a research fellow at the Canadian Centre for Management Development (now part of the Canada School of Public Service) from 1990 to 1991.[12]

In April 1986, Stéphane Dion married Janine Krieber, and later the same year, they travelled to Peru to adopt their only child, Jeanne.[11] Janine Krieber, an "expert in strategic studies and counter-terrorism issues,"[5] now teaches political science and sociology at Royal Military College Saint-Jean in Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu.

Early political life

In anticipation of by-elections in early 1996, Jean Chrétien appointed two new "star candidates" from Quebec — Stéphane Dion and Pierre Pettigrew — to Cabinet. On 25 January 1996, Dion was named Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs, Pettigrew was named Minister for International Cooperation, and both were sworn into the Queen's Privy Council for Canada.

Chrétien felt safe in appointing Dion to Cabinet because Dion was slated to run in Saint-Laurent—Cartierville, the second-safest Liberal riding in Quebec. In the 25 March by-election, he was easily elected. This was not without precedent; in 1941, Mackenzie King had appointed Louis St. Laurent to Cabinet after nominating him to run in a safe Quebec riding. Dion won a full term in the general election of 1997, and was reelected again in the 2000, 2004, 2006, 2008, and 2011 elections.

Dion continued to serve as Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs until the end of Jean Chrétien's ministry on 12 December 2003.

Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs (January 1996 – December 2003)

Clarity of referendum question

In his responsibilities as Intergovernmental Affairs minister in the Jean Chrétien government, Dion was tasked with challenging the arguments of the Quebec sovereignty movement much more vigorously than in the pre-referendum period. The people of Quebec voted against the sovereignty option by a razor-thin margin (50.58% to 49.42%). Many federalists in Ottawa were caught off-guard by the results and believed that the referendum results would have no legal standing under Canadian law. The strongest complaints were on the presumed ambiguity of the 1995 question and that Quebec had tabled a law reserving the right for the National Assembly to declare independence unilaterally if constitutional negotiations with the Government of Canada failed.

Supreme Court reference re secession of Quebec

On 30 September 1996, Dion submitted three questions to the Supreme Court of Canada constituting the Supreme Court Reference re Secession of Quebec:

  1. Under the Constitution of Canada, can the National Assembly, legislature, or government of Quebec effect the secession of Quebec from Canada unilaterally?
  2. Does international law give the National Assembly, legislature, or government of Quebec the right to effect the secession of Quebec from Canada unilaterally? In this regard, is there a right to self-determination under international law that would give the National Assembly, legislature or government of Quebec the right to effect the secession of Quebec from Canada unilaterally?
  3. In the event of a conflict between domestic and international law on the right of the National Assembly, legislature, or government of Quebec to effect the secession of Quebec from Canada unilaterally, which would take precedence in Canada?

As soon as these questions were made public, both parties of the National Assembly, the Bloc Québécois and numerous federalists denounced Ottawa's gesture. An Act respecting the exercise of the fundamental rights and prerogatives of the Québec people and the Québec State was passed in the National Assembly of Quebec by the Parti Québécois government two days after the Clarity Act had been introduced in the Canadian House of Commons.

On 20 August 1998, the Supreme Court answered, concluding that Quebec does not have the right to secede unilaterally under Canadian or international law. However, the federal government would have to enter into negotiations with the Quebec government if Quebecers expressed a clear will to secede. It confirmed that the Canadian Parliament had the power to determine whether or not a referendum question was clear enough to trigger such negotiations. The Canadian constitution would remain in effect until terms of secession were agreed to by all parties involved, and these terms would have to respect principles of democracy, minority and individual rights as outlined in the Canadian constitution.[15]

Both the government of Quebec and the government of Canada publicly stated that they were very pleased with the opinion of the Supreme Court, which stated both that Quebec could not legally separate unilaterally from Canada and that the Canadian Parliament would have a 'political obligation' to enter into separation negotiations with Quebec in the event that a clear majority of its populace were to vote in favour of independence.

Three letters

The Supreme Court reference launched a public debate between Dion and members of the Parti Québécois government in open letters published in the press.[16][17][18] Following Lucien Bouchard's open letter to the Premier of New Brunswick, Frank McKenna, in 1997 defending the legality of a unilateral secession, Dion wrote the first of three open letters to leaders in the sovereignty movement. Dion challenged three assertions that Bouchard had made: that a unilateral declaration of independence is supported by international law; that a majority of "50% plus one" was a sufficient threshold for secession; and that international law would protect the territorial integrity of Quebec following a secession. Against the first assertion, Dion argued that the vast majority of international law experts "believe that the right to declare secession unilaterally does not belong to constituent entities of a democratic country such as Canada."[16] In regard to the simple majority argument, Dion argued that due to the momentous changes to Quebecers' lives that would result from secession, a simple majority that could disappear in the face of difficulties would be insufficient to ensure the political legitimacy of the sovereigntist project. In regard to the territorial integrity of Quebec, Dion retorts that "there is neither a paragraph nor a line in international law that protects Quebec's territory but not Canada's. International experience demonstrates that the borders of the entity seeking independence can be called into question, sometimes for reasons based on democracy."[16]

Dion's second open letter, to Quebec's intergovernmental affairs minister Jacques Brassard, came on 19 November 1997. Dion expanded upon his earlier arguments against the territorial integrity of Quebec following secession by highlighting the inconsistency in the argument that Canada is divisible but Quebec is not. Secondly, Dion underscored that without recognition by the Government of Canada and when opposed by a strong minority of citizens, a unilateral declaration of independence faces much difficulty in gaining international recognition.[17]

In Dion's third open letter to Premier Lucien Bouchard came on 25 August 1998, shortly after the Supreme Court ruling on Secession had been handed down. He criticized the Quebec premier for accepting some aspects of the ruling (such as the political obligation for the Government of Canada to negotiate secession following a clear expression of will from the people of Quebec) and not other sections of the ruling (such as the need for a clear majority on a clear question and the unconstitutionality of a unilateral declaration of independence). In regard to the ruling, Dion makes three claims: that the federal government has a role in the selection of the question and the level of support required for it to pass, that secession can only be achieved through negotiation rather than a "unilateral declaration of independence", and that the terms of negotiation could not be decided solely by the Government of Quebec.[18]

First International Conference on Federalism

Dion organized and hosted the First International Conference on Federalism in Mont Tremblant in October 1999 to foster international support for the cause of federalism in Canada. Quebec sovereigntist leaders were granted a prominent role in the conference and used their floor time to denounce Canadian federalism to an international audience to the great annoyance of their federalist host. But Dion's views got a big boost during the closing speech by United States President Bill Clinton. Clinton appeared to echo the Supreme Court Reference, warning that "when a people thinks it should be independent in order to have a meaningful political existence, serious questions should be asked.... Are minority rights as well as majority rights respected? How are we going to co-operate with our neighbours?". Clinton argued that federalism allows peoples seeking recognition of their identity a way to do so without isolating themselves in a nation-state. The speech laid to rest any doubts about the U.S. position on the legality and desirability of unilateral secession in Quebec.[19]

Clarity Act

The Supreme Court reference and three letters formed the basis for the Clarity Act (Bill C-20) presented by Dion to the House of Commons on 13 December 1999.[20] The legislation established the conditions under which the Government of Canada would enter into negotiations that might lead to secession following a vote by one of the provinces. It stipulated that in order to lead to separation negotiations, a referendum on independence in a given province would have to have "clearly" (according to the judgement of the Canadian House of Commons) framed its question to voters in terms of independence, and that the result would have to be a "clear majority" in favour, rather than a "50% plus one" majority. It was passed by the House on 15 March 2000

Reactions to Clarity Act

"No, Mr Dion, it's not paranoia, people really do hate you!" (cartoon by Serge Chapleau, 1997)

The Clarity Act was supported by the Liberals and Reform Party in Parliament. Most in the New Democratic Party (NDP) supported it. The Progressive Conservative Party, led by Joe Clark, also opposed the Act. The Act was more bitterly denounced by all provincial parties in the Quebec National Assembly, the Bloc Québécois, and many Quebec federalists. Following its adoption by Parliament, an open letter supporting Quebec's right to self-determination was published and signed by numerous intellectuals from Quebec and other parts of Canada. William Johnson, leader of Quebec's largest anglophone rights group, Alliance Quebec, said the Act would prevent misinformation by sovereigntists on the topic of secession.[21]

Dion's vigorous opposition to Quebec sovereigntist claims appears to have had the desired effect: support for sovereignty-association plummeted to 24% in October 1999 after the Supreme Court reference.[22] Jean Chrétien cites the act as one of his greatest achievements as Prime Minister. Attacks on the Act also were aimed at Dion personally in Quebec under the perception that he had undermined fundamental democratic rights to self-determination. Serge Chapleau, the caricaturist for La Presse, began portraying Dion as a rat, while Parti Québécois leader Bernard Landry called Dion "the most hated politician in the history of Quebec" ("le politicien le plus détesté de l'histoire du Québec").[23]

Views on federalism

Dion has often been described in Quebec as a Trudeau centralist due to his strong defence of Canadian federalism and forceful arguments against Quebec sovereigntists. However, his position on federalism is far more nuanced. It would be most accurate to describe him as a federal autonomist. While Dion supports cooperation, flexibility, and interdependence in the Canadian federation, he unequivocally argues against jurisdictional intrusion, stating

[T]he Constitution must be respected. We must do away with the all-too-convenient excuse that a given governmental initiative responds to a need that is too urgent to be stymied by issues of "jurisdiction". Infringement of jurisdiction creates confusion which damages the quality of public policy.

Dion's position on provincial rights is not only the result of respect for the Constitution of Canada, but also a strategy to prevent the "joint decision trap" in which the capacity of a government's ability to act is restricted by the need for approval from the other constituent governments.

Dion has contested the political concentration on the division of powers between the federal and provincial governments, arguing that:

[I]dentity, rather than the division of powers, that is at the source of our unity problem. Francophone Quebecers want the assurance that their language and culture can flourish with the support of other Canadians. They want to feel that their language and culture are seen by other Canadians as an important asset, rather than a burden. They want the assurance that they can be both Quebecers and Canadians, and that they don't have to choose between Quebec and Canada.[24]

In the same vein, Dion was the planner of the 1999 Social Union Framework Agreement, which, according to journalist Duncan Cameron, limited the national spending jurisdiction. Dion has described Quebec's Bill 101 as "a great law".[25]

Gomery inquiry and 2004 election (January–July 2004)

Dion had a prominent role within the Chrétien administration at the time of the sponsorship scandal, and his position as "National Unity" minister (an unofficial term for the Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs) made him a figure of particular interest to the subsequent Commission of Inquiry into the Sponsorship Program and Advertising Activities (the Gomery Commission). He stated before the Gomery Commission that although in mid-2001 he was aware of the disproportionately large percentage of sponsorship funds going to Quebec, he was never directly involved in the administration of the program.[26] Indeed, Dion had been critical of the program while in cabinet, and openly doubted that it would do much to sway Quebecers from sovereignty.[27] Along with most of the other ministers in the Chrétien cabinet, Dion was exonerated of all responsibility in the affair in the Phase I report of the Gomery Commission:

"On the evidence there is no basis for attributing blame or responsibility to any other Minister of the Chrétien Cabinet [excepting Jean Chrétien and Alfonso Gagliano], since they, like all members of Parliament, were not informed of the initiatives being authorized by Mr. [Jean] Pelletier and their funding from the Unity Reserve."[28]

In early 2007, after winning the Liberal Party leadership, Dion suggested that [29][30]


27th Ministry – Cabinet of Paul Martin
Cabinet Post (1)
Predecessor Office Successor
David Anderson Minister of the Environment
Rona Ambrose
26th Ministry – Cabinet of Jean Chrétien
Cabinet Posts (2)
Predecessor Office Successor
Marcel Massé Minister of Intergovernmental Affairs
Pierre Pettigrew
Marcel Massé President of the Queen's Privy Council for Canada
Denis Coderre
Order of precedence
Preceded by
Jane Stewart
Canadian order of precedence
as of 2010
Succeeded by
Pierre Pettigrew
  • How'd They Vote?: Stéphane Dion's voting history and quotes
  • Stéphane Dion – Parliament of Canada biography
  • Canadian Encyclopedia entry on Stéphane Dion

External links

  1. ^ Stéphane Dion finds God. Retrieved 10 October 2008.
  2. ^
  3. ^ Government of Canada (5 January 2015). "Historical alphabetical list since 1867". Members of the Queen's Privy Council for Canada. Privy Council Office. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  4. ^ Benoit Aubin. "Dion, Stéphane (Profile)". Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  5. ^ a b Ha, Tu Thanh (6 September 2006). "Straight shooter looks to lead". Toronto: The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  6. ^ Robitaille, Antoine (9 December 2006). "Dion contre Dion". Le Devoir. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  7. ^ Dion, Stéphane (January 1979). La dimension temporelle de l'action partisane : l'étude d'un cas : le débat au sein du Parti Québécois sur les modalités d'accession à l'indépendance. (print only) (in French). Université Laval (Thèse, M.A.). p. 132. 
  8. ^ a b c Diebel, Linda (13 August 2006). "Can Stéphane Dion reel in the prize?" (link not available). The Toronto Star. Retrieved 4 September 2006. 
  9. ^ Aubin, Benoit (22 January 2007). "Ottawa's new power couple" (link not available). Macleans. Retrieved 4 February 2007. 
  10. ^ a b Vastel, Michel (15 April 1997). "Dion Quichotte mission impossible". L'actualité. Archived from the original on 27 September 2007. Retrieved 16 December 2006.  (en français seulement)
  11. ^ a b Heinrich, Jeff (9 December 2006). "Stéphane Dion, unmasked". The Gazette. Retrieved 18 December 2006. 
  12. ^ a b Privy Council Office (25 January 1996). "Prime Minister announces new Ministry". Government of Canada. Retrieved 18 December 2006. 
  13. ^ Library of Parliament (2006). "Dion, Stéphane: Selected Publications" (link not available). Government of Canada. Retrieved 18 December 2006. 
  14. ^ Dion, Stéphane (November 1999). Straight Talk (print) (in English (translated)). McGill-Queen's University Press. p. 256.  
  15. ^ Supreme Court of Canada (20 August 1998). "Reference re Secession of Quebec". Supreme Court of Canada. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  16. ^ a b c Dion, Stéphane (11 August 1997). "Letter to Premier Lucien Bouchard Concerning his Position on a Unilateral Declaration of Independence". Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs Canada. Retrieved 4 December 2006. 
  17. ^ a b Dion, Stéphane (19 November 1997). "Letter to Mr. Jacques Brassard in Response to his Ministerial Statement on the Territorial Integrity of Quebec". Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs Canada. Retrieved 4 December 2006. 
  18. ^ a b Dion, Stéphane (25 August 1998). "Letter to Premier Lucien Bouchard on the Need to Respect the Supreme Court's Decision in its Entirety". Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs Canada. Retrieved 4 December 2006. 
  19. ^ Bruce Wallace (18 October 1999). "Clinton Defends Canadian Federalism". Maclean's Magazine. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  20. ^ "Clarity Act". Government of Canada Privy Council Office. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  21. ^ "PQ takes clarity bill complaints to Ottawa". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 11 November 2000. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  22. ^ "Introducing the Clarity Bill" (media: video). Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 14 December 1999. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  23. ^ Dutrisac, Robert (24 January 2001). "Le ton change face au fédéral". Le Devoir. 
  24. ^ Dion, Stéphane (28 May 1998). "My Praxis of Federalism" (Notes for an address at the Institute of Intergovernmental Relations, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario). Retrieved 16 December 2006. 
  25. ^ "Hébert: Language law to face foe from within". Toronto: 2 November 2009. Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  26. ^  
  27. ^ "Stéphane Dion, inconspicuous achiever". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. October 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. Dion testified he was aware of the unusually large amounts of money going to Quebec under the sponsorship program but he knew nothing about the way the program was administered and said he had been critical from the outset of the idea that it would do anything to sway the minds of Quebecers. 
  28. ^  
  29. ^ Bryden, Joan (24 January 2007). "Dion could welcome back some sponsorship organizers". CP. Retrieved 26 January 2007. 
  30. ^ Campbell Clark and Jane Taber (25 January 2007). "Dion backtracks on return of party exile". Globe and Mail (Toronto). Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  31. ^ CTV News Staff (16 February 2004). "Doer: PM's Quebec policy hinders Grits in West: Doer". CTV News. Retrieved 30 December 2006. 
  32. ^ CTV News Staff (29 June 2004). "Duceppe: Bloc win a step towards sovereignty". CTV News. Retrieved 30 December 2006. 
  33. ^ Simpson, Jeffrey (21 July 2004). "Not Exactly a Brave New Cabinet". Globe and Mail (Toronto). Archived from the original on 27 April 2006. Retrieved 28 December 2006. 
  34. ^ Mitchell, Alanna (12 October 2004). "An Environment Minister of another colour" (MS Word doc from Michael Keating, Bingera Associates). Globe and Mail ( Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  35. ^ a b Dion, Stéphane (10 September 2004). "Environmental action for economic competitiveness: Will Canada lead the new Industrial Revolution?". Environment Canada. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  36. ^ Geddes, John (22 February 2005). "Rocky ride for Dion?". Macleans Magazine. Archived from the original on 8 March 2005. Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  37. ^ Bueckert, Dennis (14 October 2005). "Former industry exec to head Clean Fund: report". Canadian Press ( Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  38. ^ Environment Canada (22 October 2004). "Minister of the Environment Makes Recommendations on Adding New Species to the Species at Risk Act". Environment Canada (Canada News Wire). Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  39. ^ Mitchell, Alanna (23 October 2004). "Never before has the federal government consciously decided to let something go extinct" (PDF). Globe and Mail (University of Toronto, Dept. of Zoology). Retrieved 4 January 2007. 
  40. ^ Heinrich, Jeff (11 December 2005). "Canada: Dion praised for extending Kyoto accord". Montreal Gazette. Retrieved 6 January 2007. 
  41. ^ Galloway, Gloria (15 December 2005). "Online campaign asks Canadians to back Green Party inclusion in election debates". Globe and Mail. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  42. ^ Francoeur, Louis-Gilles (9 December 2006). "Faut-il déboulonner la statue verte de Dion?". Le Devoir. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  43. ^ David Suzuki Foundation (13 April 2005). "Canada's climate change plan lacks teeth". David Suzuki Foundation. Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  44. ^ Canadian Press (29 September 2005). "Environment Commissioner Gives Government Failing Marks Over Policies". Canadian Press ( Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  45. ^ CBC News (29 September 2005). "Watchdog says Ottawa not protecting environment". CBC. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  46. ^ Williams, Howard (30 September 2005). "Canada's Pro-Kyoto Gov't Accused of Hypocrisy Over Environment". CNSNews. Archived from the original on 29 September 2007. Retrieved 3 January 2007. 
  47. ^ Ljunggren, David (29 September 2005). "Official Report Slams Canada over Environment". Reuters ( Retrieved 3 January 2007. 
  48. ^ Ivison, John (1 July 2006). "Dion admits Liberals' Kyoto goal impossible". National Post. Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  49. ^ Clark, Campbell; Karen Howlett (4 April 2006). "Ignatieff, Dion to launch bids this week". Globe and Mail (Toronto). Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  50. ^ CBC News (5 November 2006). "INTERVIEW: Stéphane Dion". Archived from the original (television transcript) on 11 December 2006. Retrieved 16 December 2006. 
  51. ^ Clark, Campbell (17 February 2006). "Leadership contenders define issues". Globe and Mail (Toronto). Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  52. ^ New Democratic Party (12 September 2006). "Jack Layton's keynote address to NDP convention". New Democratic Party of Canada. Archived from the original on 19 December 2006. Retrieved 2 January 2007. 
  53. ^ Gesture' might have helped trigger Dion win"'". Montreal: 2 December 2006. Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  54. ^ CBC News (19 December 2006). "Dion taps former rivals for election roles". CBC News. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  55. ^ CBC news (5 January 2007). "Liberal MP with Tory advisory role will not defect: Dion". CBC. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  56. ^ CBC news (5 January 2007). "Ontario MP Khan leaves Liberals to join Tories". CBC. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  57. ^ Fitzpatrick, Meagan (18 January 2007). "Dion names mix of old and new to shadow cabinet". National Post. Retrieved 18 January 2007. 
  58. ^ National Post (20 March 2007). "Opposition leaders weigh in". Retrieved 20 March 2007. 
  59. ^ "Tories launch attack ads aimed at Dion". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 29 January 2007. 
  60. ^ "New set of Tory ads take aim at Dion leadership". News. 2 November 2007. 
  61. ^ Smith, Joanna (3 June 2008). "MPs vote to give asylum to U.S. military deserters". The Toronto Star. Retrieved 19 July 2008. 
  62. ^ "Report — Iraq War Resisters / Rapport –Opposants à la guerre en Irak". House of Commons / Chambre des Communes, Ottawa, Canada. Retrieved 9 June 2008. 
  63. ^ "Official Report * Table of Contents * Number 104 (Official Version)". House of Commons / Chambre des Communes, Ottawa, Canada. Retrieved 9 June 2008. 
  64. ^ a b CBC News (1 February 2007). "Dion calls on Tories to recommit to Kyoto". CBC. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  65. ^ "Climate report predicts major consequences for Canada". CBC. 2 February 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  66. ^ "House motion passes supporting Kyoto". CBC. 5 February 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  67. ^ "MPs vote against extending anti-terrorism measures". CBC. 27 February 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  68. ^ "Liberals agree not to run candidate against Green leader". CBC. 12 April 2007. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  69. ^ NDP (13 April 2007). "Jack Layton on the Liberal – Green deal". NDP. Archived from the original on 18 April 2007. Retrieved 13 April 2007. 
  70. ^ CTV news staff (15 April 2007). "May says Layton has refused to talk with Greens". CTV. Retrieved 15 April 2007. 
  71. ^ Canadian Press (13 April 2007). "Courageous or disastrous? Liberals mixed about Dion's pact with May". Retrieved 13 April 2007. 
  72. ^ Bailey, Ian (15 April 2007). "No more favours for Greens, says Libs' Dion". Vancouver Province. Retrieved 15 April 2007. 
  73. ^ Canwest News Services (9 November 2007). "Dion vows to reduce poverty". The Ottawa Citizen. 
  74. ^ Dion's misuse of poverty stats, Alex MacMillan, National Post, 22 January 2008. Retrieved 27 January 2008.
  75. ^ [4]
  76. ^ Campbell, Clark, Daniel Leblanc (15 September 2007). "Outremont by-election a test for Dion". Globe & Mail (Toronto). Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  77. ^ "Not the final verdict on Dion". Globe and Mail. 19 September 2007. 
  78. ^ [5]
  79. ^ Jane Taber (19 September 2007). " Front". Toronto: Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  80. ^ Delacourt, Susan (22 September 2007). "The Liberal affliction: Runner-up syndrome". Iggy's Cross (Ottawa Bureau: Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  81. ^ Offman, Craig (22 September 2007). "Discreet signs of a mutiny". National Post. Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  82. ^ "Liberals shut out in Quebec byelections". CBC. 17 September 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  83. ^ "Dion rejects calls for removal of party's director". CBC. 28 September 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  84. ^ CTV news (10 October 2007). "Carroll resigns as Liberal party's national director". CTV. Retrieved 12 October 2007. 
  85. ^ "Dion names senator as Quebec lieutenant; 2 MPs refuse job". 16 October 2007. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  86. ^ CTV News (17 October 2007). "Harper gives Dion another election challenge". Retrieved 17 October 2007. 
  87. ^ CTV News (24 October 2007). "Throne speech passes, Liberals abstain from voting". CTV. 
  88. ^ [6]
  89. ^ Barry, Martin C. (18 October 2007). "Laval News Online". The Laval News. Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  90. ^ Zosia Bielski (18 March 2007). "Dion declares victory after by-election wins". Retrieved 18 March 2008. 
  91. ^ Gloria Galloway (18 March 2007). "Liberals win in Toronto, B.C., lose in Sask.". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  92. ^ Joan Bryden (18 March 2007). "Mixed byelection results prolong Liberal angst over election timing". Retrieved 18 March 2008. 
  93. ^ "Dion accuses cabinet minister of security breach, calls for resignation".  
  94. ^ CTV (14 March 2008). "Dion calls for a price on carbon, but not a tax". 
  95. ^ CTV (15 May 2008). "Dion says Canadians willing to accept carbon tax". 
  96. ^ CTV (18 May 2008). "Suzuki slams NDP, Tories, backs Dion's carbon tax". 
  97. ^ CTV (20 June 2008). "PM: Liberal carbon plan will 'screw' Canadians". 
  98. ^ CTV (21 June 2008). "Carbon tax about Canada's future: Dion". 
  99. ^ Gloria Galloway (11 September 2008). "Layton lays into Green Shift". Montreal: The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  100. ^ (10 July 2008). "'"Dion calls 'Green Shift' lawsuit 'deplorable. 
  101. ^ "Print Article". Toronto: 17 October 2008. Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  102. ^ a b "Dion's wife offers scathing Facebook view of Ignatieff". 22 November 2009. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  103. ^ Bonoguore, Tenille (20 October 2008). "Dion quits, but to remain at the helm until May".  
  104. ^ Taber, Jane (16 October 2008). "'"Dion ignored advisers' advice, preferring to act as 'a lone wolf.  
  105. ^ Whittington, Les; Campion-Smith, Bruce (21 October 2008). "Dion out as Liberal leader".  
  106. ^ "NDP, Liberals reach deal to topple minority Tory government".  
  107. ^ "Liberals, NDP, Bloc sign deal on proposed coalition".  
  108. ^ "How Dion's address went horribly wrong". OTTAWA: Canwest News Service. 4 December 2008. Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  109. ^ "Text of Liberal Leader Stéphane Dion's address". OTTAWA: THE CANADIAN PRESS. 3 December 2008. Retrieved 11 January 2009. 
  110. ^ "GG agrees to suspend Parliament until January".  
  111. ^ "Liberals propose plan to speed up Dion departure". The Guardian. 6 December 2008. Retrieved 30 January 2015. 
  112. ^ "Dion will bow out early to clear way for successor". CBC News. 8 December 2008. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  113. ^ JOAN BRYDEN The Canadian Press (20 October 2008). "Dion only second Liberal leader not to become prime minister". Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  114. ^ Macdonald, Nancy (2 May 2009). "Farewell to all that: At the Dion tribute — Canada Blog". Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  115. ^ Wherry, Aaron (7 September 2010). "Shadow cabinet shuffle". MacLeans Magazine. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  116. ^ a b Taber, Jane (5 June 2011). "Stéphane Dion steps out of the Liberal shadows". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  117. ^ Erikson, Krista (21 September 2009). "Ignatieff rejects Cauchon's bid to re-enter politics". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  118. ^ "Liberal MP Coderre quits as Quebec lieutenant". Canadian Broadcasting corporation. 28 September 2009. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  119. ^ "Story — News". Vancouver Sun. Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  120. ^ "Political scientist predicted Michael Ignatieff's woes | Vancouver, Canada". 22 November 2009. Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  121. ^ "CTV Toronto — Stéphane Dion's wife criticizes Ignatieff on Facebook — CTV News". Retrieved 28 April 2010. 
  122. ^ "Harper: Majority win turns page on uncertainties". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. 2 May 2011. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  123. ^ Payton, Laura (2 May 2011). "NDP surge in Quebec wipes out Bloc". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  124. ^ Bailey, Ian (19 June 2011). "Former Liberal leader Dion makes appearance at NDP convention". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 27 August 2012. 
  125. ^ Migneault, Jonathan (5 October 2015). "Liberals would meet with provinces on health care: Dion". Sudbury Northern Life. Retrieved 30 October 2015. 
  126. ^ Goldenberg, Joel (21 October 2015). "Dion wins easily in St. Laurent". The Suburban. Retrieved 30 October 2015. 
  127. ^ Authier, Philip (26 November 2006). "Dion positions himself as potential kingmaker" (reprint). National Post. Retrieved 4 December 2006. 
  128. ^ "Dion not first Liberal to call his dog Kyoto" (reprint). Canada News. 1 February 2007. Retrieved 2 February 2007. 
  129. ^ "Pie throwers tossed suspended sentences". 10 November 2000. Retrieved 2 April 2014. 
  130. ^  
  131. ^ Elections Canada – Confirmed candidates for Saint-Laurent, 30 September 2015
  132. ^ Elections Canada – Preliminary Election Expenses Limits for Candidates
  133. ^ CBC. "Canada Votes". Canada Votes 2011 – CBC. Retrieved 3 May 2011. 

Notes and references

By-election on 1996

Shirley Maheu appointment to the Senate, 31 January 1996

Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Liberal Stéphane Dion 21,336 79.3%
Bloc Québécois Michel Sarra-Bournet 4,000 14.9%
Progressive Conservative G. Garo Toubi 699 13.9%
Reform Shaul Petel 441 1.6%
Independent Carole Caron 229 0.9%
New Democratic Sara Mayo 212 0.8%
Total valid votes 26,917 100.0%
Canadian federal election, 1997: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆% Expenditures
Liberal Stéphane Dion 34,598 70.14 $39,617
     Progressive Conservative Jean-Martin Masse 6,861 13.91 $17,038
Bloc Québécois Yves Beauregard 6,276 12.72 $20,834
New Democratic Jeff Itcush 910 1.84 $850
Reform Hagop Karlozian 681 1.38 $1,907
Total valid votes 49,326 100.00
Total rejected ballots 781
Turnout 50,107 76.96
Electors on the lists 65,105
Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.
Canadian federal election, 2000: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆% Expenditures
Liberal Stéphane Dion 32,861 73.58 +3.44 $44,754
Bloc Québécois Yves Beauregard 5,838 13.07 +0.35 $11,158
     Progressive Conservative J. Pierre Rouleau 2,308 5.17 −8.74 $876
Alliance Kaddis R. Sidaros 1,909 4.27 +2.89 $8,762
New Democratic Piper Elizabeth Huggins 1,070 2.40 +0.56 $908
Marxist–Leninist Jean-Paul Bedard 234 0.52 $10
Canadian Action Ken Fernandez 232 0.52 $3,062
Communist Oscar Chavez 206 0.46 $187
Total valid votes 44,658 100.00
Total rejected ballots 642
Turnout 45,300 63.06 −13.90
Electors on the lists 71,836
Canadian Alliance percentages are contrasted with the Reform Party figures from 1997. Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.
Canadian federal election, 2004: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆% Expenditures
Liberal Stéphane Dion 28,107 66.82 −6.51 $56,588
Bloc Québécois William Fayad 7,261 17.26 +4.04 $9,302
New Democratic Zaid Mahayni 2,630 6.25 +3.85 $11,340
Conservative Marc Rahmé 2,606 6.20 −3.32 $10,128
Green Almaz Aladass 875 2.08 $0
Marijuana Alex Néron 298 0.71 none listed
Marxist–Leninist Fernand Deschamps 125 0.30 none listed
Canadian Action Ken Fernandez 84 0.20 $116
Communist Nilda Vargas 78 0.19 $647
Total valid votes 42,064 100.00
Total rejected ballots 400
Turnout 42,464 54.28
Electors on the lists 78,238
Percentage change figures are factored for redistribution. Conservative Party percentages are contrasted with the combined Canadian Alliance and Progressive Conservative figures from 2000. Sources: Official Results, Elections Canada and Financial Returns, Elections Canada.
Canadian federal election, 2006: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆%
Liberal Stéphane Dion 25,412 59.8% -7.0%
Bloc Québécois William Fayad 6,192 14.6% -2.7%
Conservative Ishrat Alam 5,590 13.2% +7.0%
New Democratic Liz Elder 3,279 7.7% +1.5%
Green Gilles Mercier 1,810 4.3% +2.2%
Marxist–Leninist Fernand Deschamps 177 0.4% +0.1%
Total valid votes 42,460 100.0%
Canadian federal election, 2008: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆%
Liberal Stéphane Dion 25,095 61.7% +1.9%
Conservative Dennis Galiatsatos 6,999 17.2% +4.0%
Bloc Québécois Jacques Lachaine 4,611 11.3% -3.2%
New Democratic Jérôme Rodrigues 3,654 9.0% +1.3%
Marxist–Leninist Fernand Deschamps 299 0.7% +0.3%
Total valid votes 40,658 100.0%
Total rejected ballots 454
Turnout 41,112 %

Source: Elections Canada

Canadian federal election, 2011: Saint-Laurent—Cartierville
Party Candidate Votes % ∆%
Liberal Stéphane Dion 17,726 43.43
New Democratic Marias Ximena Florez 11,948 29.28
Conservative Svetlana Litvin Fayad 7,124 17.46
Bloc Québécois William Fayad 2,981 7.3
Green Tim Landry 857 2.1
Marxist–Leninist Fernand Deschamps 176 0.43
Total valid votes 100.0%[133]
Canadian federal election, 2015: Saint-Laurent
Party Candidate Votes % ∆%
Liberal Stéphane Dion 24,832 61.6 +18.74
Conservative Jimmy Yu 7,867 19.5 +0.39
New Democratic Alain Ackad 4,646 11.5 -17.57
Bloc Québécois Pascal-Olivier Dumas-Dubreuil 1,879 4.7 -1.73
Green John Tromp 977 2.4 +0.31
Marxist–Leninist Fernand Deschamps 129 0.3
Total valid votes/ 40,330 100.0    
Total rejected ballots 409
Turnout 40,739
Eligible voters 69,078
Source: Elections Canada[131][132]

Electoral record

Dion holds dual citizenship in France because of his French-born mother.[130]

In May 1999, Dion was the object of a pie-in-the-face gag orchestrated by the Montreal group, les Entartistes. The group's stated focus is to "deflate" influential political figures, and they have successfully pied several Canadian federal and provincial politicians, with past targets including Jean Chrétien and Ralph Klein. Dion was not amused and pressed charges, resulting in convictions of assault against two members of the pie-throwing group.[129] They were given suspended sentences.

Dion is married to Janine Krieber, whom he met while undergoing political science studies at Laval University. Dion's family has a husky named "Kyoto" which they purchased "to cheer themselves up after the Liberals lost the 2006 election."[127] However, Dion was not the first environment minister or Liberal to have a dog by that name. David Anderson also has a schnauzer named Kyoto which he purchased one week after Canada's ratification of the Kyoto Accord.[128]

Personal life

Dion campaigned outside his riding for much of the 2015 federal election, visiting areas such as Sudbury, Ontario to support local candidates and attack the Conservative government's record on the environment and healthcare.[125] The 2015 election was a resounding victory for Justin Trudeau's Liberal Party, and Dion was comfortably re-elected to an eighth term representing the newly-reformulated Saint-Laurent riding.[126]

2015 federal election

Since his re-election in May 2011, Dion has had a much more prominent role within the Liberal caucus than he had after his resignation as leader in 2008. Interim Liberal leader Bob Rae appointed Dion as the Liberals Critic for Intergovernmental Affairs and spokesman for la Francophonie.[116] A month after the election Dion attended the NDP's federal convention as the observer for the Liberal Party, at that time he called on NDP leader not to appease separatists as a way to maintain his party's support in Quebec. He also criticized the NDPs policy that 50-per-cent-plus-one in a referendum would justify Quebec separating from Canada.[124]

The Liberal Party fell to third place on 2 May 2011, in a federal election for the first time in Canadian history.[122] The party won just 19 per cent of the popular vote, down from the 26 per cent the party won under Dion, and elected only 34 MPs. The New Democratic Party formed the Official Opposition, mainly as a result of a surge in support in Quebec. Dion was one of just seven Liberal MPs re-elected in his home province, he won 43.43 per cent of the popular in his riding which was the highest vote share for a Liberal in Quebec.[123]

2011 federal election

An 25 October 2009, poll suggested that Ignatieff had a lower popularity than Dion at his worst showing as Liberal leader.[119] A month later Dion's wife Janine Krieber wrote a scathing letter on her Facebook page in which she suggested that the Liberal Party was in full collapse and the future appeared bleak.[120] She questioned Ignatieff's ability to lead the party out of its current woes, alleging that party members were duped by Ignatieff and would have recognized his obvious shortcomings if they'd only taken the time to read his academic writings. Krieber claimed that Dion was working to rebuild the party after the disappointing 2008 election, but their efforts were stymied by Ignatieff, who turned down the coalition with the other opposition parties, and who "dethroned Dion without a leadership race". Dion was said to have no involvement in the criticism letter and later asked Kreiber to remove the Facebook post, which talks of deep divisions in the Liberal Party.[102][121]

In September 2009, it was reported that Denis Coderre, Ignatieff's Quebec lieutenant, was attempting to oust Dion and fellow Montreal-area MPs Raymonde Folco, Lise Zarac, and Bernard Patry for the next election, with the hope of replacing them with star candidates.[117] However, Coderre ended up resigning as Quebec Lieutenant during this time over conflicting views with Ignatieff and his inner circle.[118]

Ignatieff appointed a smaller shadow cabinet after being named interim leader and did not give Dion a critic role within it.[115] Over the course of Ignatieff's time as leader Dion stayed out of the limelight, working quietly in his riding and expressing his views privately to Ignatieff.[116]

Dion speaks at Carleton University on 27 October 2009.

Post-leadership (January 2009-present)

Dion delivered a speech on 2 May 2009, at the Liberal Party leadership convention.[114]

Shortly afterwards, Dion came under increasing pressure from the party to immediately step down as Liberal leader.[111] On 8 December, Dion announced that he would resign the leadership soon as his successor was chosen amongst the members of the party. His resignation took effect on 10 December 2008, upon the selection of Michael Ignatieff as interim leader. This makes Dion the second permanent Liberal leader in Canadian history not to become Prime Minister, after Edward Blake in 1887.[112][113] On his retirement, Dion became the shortest serving non-interim leader of the Liberal Party since Confederation—serving for approximately four months less time (740 days to 855 days) of the next shortest serving leader, Paul Martin (2003–2006).

The Liberals and NDP reached a deal to topple the current government and form a minority coalition government, with support from the Bloc Québécois.[106] In the agreement, Dion would have been the Prime Minister (and Liberal leader) until May, when the Liberal Party would elect his successor.[107] Dion sent a letter of the plan to Governor General Michaëlle Jean, and the opposition had scheduled a non-confidence motion for 8 December 2008. To draw public support, Prime Minister Harper and Dion both addressed the nation on 3 December 2008. Dion's Liberal rebuttal, however, was considered poor in production quality and delivered late to the networks, and some believed that this had undermined support for the coalition.[108][109] On 4 December 2008, the Governor General granted Prime Minister Harper's request to suspend parliament until January 2009, thereby delaying a scheduled non-confidence vote and the likely defeat of the Conservative government.[110]

2008 parliamentary dispute

The Liberals lost support on 14 October federal election, being reduced to 77 seats, down from 103 won in the 2006 election. They captured only 26.2 per cent of the popular vote — two points lower than the disastrous showing in 1984 under John Turner and only four points ahead of the party's worst ever result in 1867. Dion said that the party lost because he did not get the Liberal message out, and took responsibility saying “If people are asking why, it's because I failed.”[103] Dion added that he never had a chance to establish his personal image with voters because of the Conservative ads depicting him as a "dithering egghead". Liberal veterans described Dion as a "lone wolf" who dismissed suggestions from his senior advisers to avoid using the Green Shift as an election platform. A party insider also said that Dion was reluctant to emphasize the Liberal team because he felt that he was being overshadowed by leadership rival Bob Rae.[104][105]


Dion's wife Janine Krieber also drew some controversy in the 2008 campaign. She complained that she was being muzzled by the Liberals, though party officials denied it. Reportedly, insiders had concerns that the outspoken Krieber would not stick to the party line and take the focus away from Dion. Krieber also refused at last minute to introduce Dion at a women's event because she felt that the brief speech prepared for her by campaign headquarters was undignified.[102]

Near the end of the campaign, Dion had an interview with CTV Halifax's anchor Steve Murphy, where Dion asked the host three times to restart the interview because he didn't understand the mixed tense and timing of a question about the economy: "If you were Prime Minister now, what would you have done about the economy and this crisis that Mr. Harper has not done?" Murphy initially agreed not to air it but network executives decided to release it, generating controversy. On election night, Dion angrily refused to speak to the CTV reporters scrumming around him, saying "The last one I want to speak first [sic] is CTV - you understand that?".[101]

Green Shift Inc., a Toronto-based consulting firm, filed an $8.5 million lawsuit against the Liberal Party on 9 July 2008, citing trademark infringement. The company also sought a court injunction against the Liberal Party to stop using the name. Dion responded that the lawsuit was "deplorable" and added that the Liberals are not a commercial company and did not see any legal problems for using the term "Green Shift".[100]

The plan was immediately criticized by Prime Minister Harper, who described it as a tax grab and compared it to the National Energy Program that the federal Liberal government adopted in the 1980s.[97][98] On 11 September 2008, NDP leader Jack Layton also criticized the Green Shift, saying that it would hurt consumers, would be nothing more than a nuisance for energy producers, and evaluates emission equally across all sectors instead of maximizing reductions where the cost is lowest. Layton further noted that Dion's proposal does not set a target for reducing emissions.[99]

In June 2008, Dion unveiled the new policy called The Green Shift (le Tournant vert) and explained that this tax shift would create an ecotax on carbon while reducing personal and corporate income taxes. He stated that the taxation on carbon would generate up to $15 billion per year in revenues to offset the reduction in income tax revenue.

In 2008, as part of a measure for cutting greenhouse emissions, Dion called for a carbon price. He also praised a similar measure introduced and approved by the British Columbia government in the 2008 provincial budget as well as the province of Quebec that introduced a carbon-based tax which revenues will be used for green technologies.[94] Critics from other parties as well as some Liberal MPs said that the concept would be "too confusing, expensive and politically risky".[95] Environmontal Minister John Baird stated that the plan was "made on Bay Street" and is actually supported by big business and polluters". The plan received support from David Suzuki who added on CTV's Question Period that: "To oppose the carbon tax plan, it's just nonsense. It's certainly the way we got to go".[96]

Dion makes a speech on 10 October 2008, in Brampton West. Former Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, seen here standing behind Dion, was among notable Liberals at this rally.

2008 federal election

In January 2008, Dion and Ignatieff went to Kandahar, Afghanistan to visit a provincial reconstruction team. The visit was supposed to be secret, but was leaked to the public by Conservative junior minister Helena Guergis. After his return, Dion angrily criticized Guergis' action, saying that she put him at risk for being attacked by the Taliban. In a letter to Harper, Dion demanded Guergis' resignation or firing, saying that Guergis committed a "gross breach of Canadian security" that raised doubts about her fitness for Cabinet.[93]

Visit to Afghanistan

The Liberal Party won three of four by-elections held on 17 March 2008, as Dion's former leadership rivals Bob Rae and Martha Hall Findlay won convincing victories in Toronto Centre and Willowdale and Joyce Murray was narrowly returned for Vancouver Quadra. The Conservatives won a fourth contest in the northern Saskatchewan riding of Desnethé—Missinippi—Churchill River, which the Liberals had narrowly taken in the previous election. Dion declared the results a victory for his party, while also noting that some Liberal support was siphoned off to the Green Party.[90] Some journalists described the outcome as a mixed result for both the Liberal Party and Dion's leadership.[91][92]

Marc Garneau initially stated that he was not part of Dion's vision after being passed over for a riding nomination. Since then, Dion and Garneau have reconciled, and Garneau ran to succeed outgoing longtime MP Lucienne Robillard in Westmount—Ville-Marie.[88][89]

Marcel Proulx resigned as Dion's Quebec lieutenant hours before the Harper government's throne speech, taking the fall for the three by-election losses. Dion first approached Montreal MPs Denis Coderre and Pablo Rodriguez to succeed Proulx, but they declined. That evening he named Senator Céline Hervieux-Payette to the vacant post.[85] While the Party was divided on whether or not the government should be toppled on a confidence vote regarding the Throne Speech, Dion mentioned in a statement in the House of Commons on 17 October that the Liberals will support the Throne Speech but with major amendments including the Kyoto Protocol and the end of mission in Afghanistan by 2009 and had criticized the government on several aspects including the economy, seniors and child poverty, the crime policy, the Senate reform. The latter amendment proposal was rejected by the New Democratic Party who are favouring an immediate end to the mission. Dion explained the decision as that Canadians are not willing to have a third election in just over three years.[86] All Liberal members abstained from voting on the Throne Speech on 24 October 2007, which passed 126–79.[87]

On 23 September 2007, Liberal Party national director Jamie Carroll sparked controversy when, during discussions about whether francophone Quebecers should be hired in order to appeal to francophone voters, he commented: "Do we also have to hire people from the Chinese community to represent the Chinese community?" Carroll argued that the comment was taken out of context, but it nevertheless raised the hackles of many Liberals in Quebec, prompting calls from MPs Pablo Rodriguez and Liza Frulla for Carroll to be fired. Stéphane Dion stood by Carroll's version of events and rejected calls for Carroll's dismissal.[83] On 10 October, a Liberal press release announced Carroll's resignation and commended him for his "loyalty to our leader and to our party".[84]

The first federal by-elections contested by the Liberals under Dion's leadership took place on 18 September 2007, in three Quebec ridings: Jean Lapierre suggested that it was due to Dion's 14% approval rating in the province.[78] In addition, the Halifax Chronicle-Herald reported that unidentified "Dion loyalists" were accusing Michael Ignatieff supporters of undermining by-election efforts. Though Ignatieff phoned up Dion to deny the allegations, the Globe and Mail suggested that the report had a negative impact on the Liberals' morale, citing the NDP's widening lead after the article's release.[79][80][81] Undaunted, Dion declared: "From this defeat, we can learn something and work together as a united party.."[82]

Internal discord

On 8 November 2007, Dion released a policy plan, that he compared to the United Kingdom's Labour Party under former Prime Minister Tony Blair. Dion mentioned that his party will tackle poverty in Canada in order to create a "greener", "richer" and "fairer" Canada. He set up targets to reduce general poverty by 30 percent and child poverty by 50 percent as well as helping working families with work rewards as well as increasing the Canada Child Tax benefit, increasing guaranteed revenues for seniors.[73] In an editorial in the National Post, economist Alex MacMillan notes that the poverty targets Dion has set are based on a Statistics Canada measure that the statistical agency has stated is not a poverty measure (LICO), and that by using what is in effect a relative income measure rather than an absolute poverty measure, Dion is essentially aiming to flatten the income distribution of Canadians.[74] However, there is no official poverty rate for Canada that Dion could otherwise use, and some other political parties also quote LICO figures as poverty rates.[75]

On 12 April 2007, Dion announced that the Liberals would not run a candidate against Green Party leader Elizabeth May in the Nova Scotia riding of Central Nova (then represented by Conservative Peter MacKay) in return for the Green Party leader's agreement not to run a Green candidate in Dion's riding of Saint-Laurent—Cartierville.[68] The deal was criticized by the Conservatives and the NDP (Jack Layton had rejected earlier attempts by May to cut a "backroom" deal with his party[69][70]), and also by some within the Liberal Party.[71] Dion later gave reassurance that the controversial deal was "an exceptional circumstance where Liberal voters are invited to help her [May] to win against Peter MacKay."[72]

On 27 February, Dion's Liberals, together with Bloc Québécois and NDP members of Parliament, voted down a Harper government proposal to extend two controversial provisions of the Anti-Terrorism Act for another three years. Dion argued that the measures — which allowed police to arrest and detain terror suspects for three days without a warrant and which allowed judges to force witnesses to testify in terror cases — "have done nothing to fight against terrorism" and "have not been helpful and have continued to create some risk for civil liberties."[67]

On 1 February, Dion tabled a motion challenging the Conservatives to reaffirm Canada's commitment to the Kyoto Protocol, attempting to capitalize on a 2002 letter in which Prime Minister Harper described the Accord as a "socialist scheme" that is based on "tentative and contradictory scientific evidence" and designed to suck money out of rich countries.[64] Tory environment minister John Baird responded by blaming the Liberals for what he described as a "shameful record over 13 years of inaction on the environment,"[64] while Stephen Harper said that his government would "stabilize emissions."[65] Dion's non-binding motion passed on 5 February.[66]

Stéphane Dion addresses a crowd during the 2008 Canadian Federal Election.

Parliamentary Opposition

On 3 June 2008, Stéphane Dion voted to implement a program which would “allow conscientious a war not sanctioned by the United in Canada...”[61][62][63]

In response, the Conservatives would launch a series of attack ads aimed directly at Dion, attacking his leadership abilities and record as Environment Minister[59] Similar ads attacking Dion would appear in November over statements that Dion would prefer new spending on health care and social programs to cuts to the Goods and Services Tax introduced by the Conservatives.[60]

On 18 January 2007, Dion unveiled the remainder of the Liberal opposition's shadow cabinet (see Official Opposition Shadow Cabinet (Canada) for a complete list of appointments).[57] Shortly after Dion led the Liberal caucus in its rejection of the 2007 Conservative budget, arguing that it failed Canadians on economic prosperity, social justice and environmental sustainability.[58]

In early January 2007, Dion made a leadership decision in regards to Wajid Khan, a Liberal MP who was serving as a Middle-East adviser to the Prime Minister. Dion thought it was inappropriate for a member of the Official Opposition to be serving the government so he told Khan to give up the position. Dion was confident that Khan would stay with the caucus and give up advising the Prime Minister,[55] but Khan chose to cross the floor, and join the Conservative caucus instead.[56]

As rumours circulated of a possible election in early 2007, Dion bolstered the image of a Liberal Party renewed and healed of its internal divisions by appointing many of his former leadership rivals to key campaign positions. Michael Ignatieff was named deputy leader, Bob Rae and Scott Brison became platform development co-chairs, Gerard Kennedy was named special adviser for election readiness and renewal, Martha Hall Findlay was charged with platform outreach, and Ken Dryden, who received special acknowledgement from Dion for being "the heart of our party", was tasked "to be everywhere".[54]

After Stéphane Dion was elected as the leader, the Liberal Party experienced a sudden surge in their poll numbers. The Conservatives regained their lead shortly thereafter, although the parties were again tied for support in the summer of 2007. (For polling specifics, see Opinion polling in the Canadian federal election, 2008.)

Mirza Masroor Ahmad (left), leader of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community, with Stéphane Dion (right), who was one of multiple party leaders to attend the grand opening of Baitun Nur, the largest mosque in Canada on 5 July 2008

Leader of Her Majesty's Opposition (December 2006 – December 2008)

On 2 December 2006, at the Liberal Party leadership convention, Dion finished third after the first ballot, garnering 17.8% of the delegates. After the second ballot, Gerard Kennedy threw his support behind Dion. Earlier, the two leadership contenders had allegedly struck a pact in which the first off the ballot would throw his support to the other. Pundits said that this surprise move had caught the Ignatieff and Rae strategists off guard.[53] When the totals of the third ballot were released, Dion held a narrow lead with 37%, followed closely by Michael Ignatieff with 34.5%. Bob Rae, with only 28.5%, freed his delegates, many of whom backed Dion, as did former leadership candidates Ken Dryden and Joe Volpe. On the fourth ballot, Dion captured 54.7% of votes cast and was declared the 11th leader of the Liberal Party of Canada.

Dion was a lower-key figure during most of the leadership race, with much of the media and political attention being centred on the race's two most high-profile candidates, Michael Ignatieff and former Ontario New Democratic Party premier Bob Rae. Federal NDP leader Jack Layton described Dion as "A man of principle and conviction and therefore almost certain not to be elected leader of the Liberal party."[52] For much of the campaign, front-runner Ignatieff had the strongest support in Dion's home province of Quebec. Dion's level of support was similar to that of former Ontario cabinet minister Gerard Kennedy, both candidates being in a distant third/fourth place, though still significantly higher than the other four leadership contestants.

Stéphane Dion announced his candidacy on 7 April, the day of the official beginning of the Liberal leadership race.[49] His leadership campaign was referred to as the three-pillar approach. This approach focused on social justice, economic prosperity, and environmental sustainability, and a claim that a combination of these pillars would bring Canada into the 21st century.[50] He said that his campaign would focus on sustainable development of the economy and creating a "hyper-educated" Canadian workforce in order to compete with China.[51]

Dion, surrounded by supporters, at the 2006 Liberal leadership convention.

Liberal leadership candidate (April–December 2006)

"Everyone is saying target, target. But ... it is to be more than to reach a target. It's to change the economy. It's to have resource productivity, energy efficiency when we know that energy will be the next crisis for the economy of the world.... All my ministries will be green. Maybe I'll make one department of industry and the environment – a department of sustainability. That's not a commitment, but if you want to change the mind, you have to change structure...."[48]

In February 2006, after the Liberals had been defeated and the Conservatives had taken over the reins of government, Dion said that Canada would very likely not be able to reach its Kyoto targets. Nevertheless, he argued that this was missing the point:

The government did not make significant progress towards reducing Canada's greenhouse gas emissions during Dion's brief tenure in office.[42] In April 2005, Dion unveiled his "Project Green" to combat climate change, but the program was immediately criticized by some environmental groups for being too timid and for lacking in meaningful regulations.[43] Johanne Gélinas, Canada's environment commissioner, criticized the government's stewardship of marine areas and national parks, as well as its efforts to ensure the safety of drinking water.[44][45][46][47]

Dion earned high praise for his work chairing the U.N. Climate Change summit (COP 11/MOP 1) in Montreal in 2005.[40] Later, when Dion's record as environment minister was under scrutiny in the closing days of the Liberal leadership campaign, former Sierra Club of Canada director and current leader of the Green Party of Canada Elizabeth May came to his defence, calling him a "very very good environment minister."[41]

Dion's ministry declined to protect Sakinaw and Cultus sockeye salmon under the Species at Risk Act because it "could cost the sockeye fishing industry $125 million in lost revenue by 2008,"[38] This led to some criticism from environmentalists.[39]

Shortly after his appointment, a Globe and Mail article described Dion as being "bent on transforming the environment dossier from the traditional tree-hugger's last stand into a forward-thinking economic portfolio.".[34] Dion championed a "new industrial revolution" focused on "environmentally sustainable technologies and products",[35] and he sought to nurture a collaborative relationship with big business rather than a confrontational one.[36] His maiden speech before the Calgary Chamber of Commerce illustrates just how accommodating he was ready to be: "Calgary is one of Canada's most impressive economic engines.... Alberta could soon be the second-largest oil-exporting jurisdiction on Earth, behind Saudi Arabia. This is tremendous blessing for Canada."[35] In October 2005, Dion nominated oil and gas executive Allan Amey to head up the government's $1-billion Clean Fund, the largest single element in Dion's Kyoto implementation strategy.[37]

Minister of the Environment (July 2004 – February 2006)

On 20 July 2004, Paul Martin appointed Dion the Minister of the Environment.[33]

At the time of the June 2004 federal election, Liberal support had dropped significantly, especially in Quebec where various members of the party had been implicated in the Sponsorship scandal. The Liberal campaign rebounded somewhat in its final days, but the Liberals were still reduced to a minority government due in part to their defeat in Quebec at the hands of the Bloc Québécois.[32]


This article was sourced from Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License; additional terms may apply. World Heritage Encyclopedia content is assembled from numerous content providers, Open Access Publishing, and in compliance with The Fair Access to Science and Technology Research Act (FASTR), Wikimedia Foundation, Inc., Public Library of Science, The Encyclopedia of Life, Open Book Publishers (OBP), PubMed, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Center for Biotechnology Information, U.S. National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health (NIH), U.S. Department of Health & Human Services, and, which sources content from all federal, state, local, tribal, and territorial government publication portals (.gov, .mil, .edu). Funding for and content contributors is made possible from the U.S. Congress, E-Government Act of 2002.
Crowd sourced content that is contributed to World Heritage Encyclopedia is peer reviewed and edited by our editorial staff to ensure quality scholarly research articles.
By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. World Heritage Encyclopedia™ is a registered trademark of the World Public Library Association, a non-profit organization.

Copyright © World Library Foundation. All rights reserved. eBooks from Project Gutenberg are sponsored by the World Library Foundation,
a 501c(4) Member's Support Non-Profit Organization, and is NOT affiliated with any governmental agency or department.